Top Rated Pizza Places in Milton

Flowers Team Real Estate • February 3, 2025

Top Rated Pizza Places in Milton: A Slice of Heaven Right Here in Town

Milton may be known for its charming neighbourhoods and thriving real estate market, but let’s talk about something just as important—pizza! Whether you're a fan of thin crust, deep dish, or classic Neapolitan-style, this town has some serious contenders for the best pizza. If you're on the hunt for your next slice of cheesy goodness, here are the top 10 pizza places in Milton that you need to try.

No matter the occasion—whether it’s game night, a weekend party, or just a late-night craving, these pizza spots have got you covered!


1. Goodfellas Wood Oven Pizza

📍 Address: 22 Ontario St S, Milton, ON

If you want authentic wood-fired pizza, Goodfellas Wood Oven Pizza is a must-visit. Their Neapolitan-style pies are cooked to perfection, with a light and airy crust. Try their Margherita Pizza for a classic Italian experience. Visit their website


2. Pizzaiolo

📍 Address: 327 Bronte St S Unit 2, Milton, ON

For a variety of gourmet and classic pizzas, Pizzaiolo is a go-to spot. They offer an extensive menu, including vegan and gluten-free options. Their Meat Lover’s Pizza is a local favourite. Visit their website


3. Big Mama's & Papa's Pizzeria

📍 Address: 785 Main St E #9, Milton, ON

If you’re craving oversized pizzas, Big Mama’s & Papa’s Pizzeria is the place to be. Their unique toppings and giant-sized pizzas make them stand out. Visit their website


4. Pasqualino

📍 Address: 248 Main St E, Milton, ON

For a high-end pizza experience, Pasqualino delivers authentic Italian-style pizza with high-quality ingredients. Their Prosciutto Arugula Pizza is a must-try. Visit their website


5. Luigi's Lasagna & Pizzeria

📍 Address: 159 Main St E, Milton, ON

A staple in Milton, Luigi’s Lasagna & Pizzeria offers hearty and delicious pizzas at affordable prices. Their Deluxe Special is a crowd favourite. Visit their website


6. City South Pizza Milton

📍 Address: 100 Bronte St S, Milton, ON

If you're looking for quick and budget-friendly takeout, City South Pizza has got you covered. Their BBQ Chicken Pizza is a standout option. Visit their website


7. Super Deal Pizza & Wings

📍 Address: 327 Bronte St S, Milton, ON

For a truly budget-friendly pizza, Super Deal Pizza & Wings delivers quality at a low price. Their Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza is perfect for a simple yet satisfying meal. Visit their website


8. Topper's Pizza

📍 Address: 10220 Derry Rd #105, Milton, ON

A Canadian favourite, Topper’s Pizza is known for its Topper’s Creamy Garlic Base and endless topping options. Their Butter Chicken Pizza is a must-try. Visit their website


9. Jopapas Pizza & Wings

📍 Address: 91 Main St E, Milton, ON

A great place for pizza and wings, Jopapas Pizza & Wings serves up delicious pizzas with generous toppings. Their Supreme Pizza is a hit among locals. Visit their website


10. Portabello's Italian Bistro

📍 Address: 101 James Snow Pkwy N, Milton, ON

For a blend of Italian cuisine and gourmet pizza, Portabello’s Italian Bistro is an excellent choice. Their Fig & Prosciutto Pizza is a delightful mix of sweet and savoury flavors. Visit their website


Special Mention: Marquee Steakhouse

📍 Address: 204 Main St E, Milton, ON

While primarily known for its premium steaks and elegant dining experience, Marquee Steakhouse also serves up some incredibly delicious wood-fired pizzas. If you're looking for a sophisticated yet comforting pizza option, this is the place to be. Visit their website


The Final Slice 🍕

Whether you're looking for authentic Italian, a quick and budget-friendly option, or something totally gourmet, Milton has a pizza spot for you. Next time you’re craving a slice—whether it’s for the big game, a weekend party, or a midnight snack—give one of these top-rated places a try!


Flowers Team News

By Flowers Team Real Estate April 10, 2025
Milton Real Estate Market Watch – March 2025 Affordability Improves While Inventory Grows: What Buyers Need to Know The Milton real estate market saw a shift in March 2025, bringing more affordability and increased inventory to the table. As borrowing costs eased and home prices edged lower compared to last year, homeownership became more attainable for many households considering a move. Prices Ease Year-Over-Year In March 2025, the average selling price in Milton was $989,662 , reflecting a 6.73% decrease compared to March 2024. The median sale price followed suit, dipping to $955,352 , down from $1,005,000 last year. While prices saw a modest month-over-month gain of 1.41% , the year-over-year dip is welcome news for buyers who were previously priced out. This trend offers a strategic opportunity for those looking to enter the market or move up, especially with interest rate cuts anticipated this spring . As TRREB President Elechia Barry-Sproule noted, “Homeownership has become more affordable over the past 12 months, and we expect further rate cuts this spring. Buyers will also benefit from increased choice, giving them greater negotiating power.” Sales-to-New-Listings Ratio Signals a Buyer’s Market With a sales-to-new-listings ratio of just 0.28 , the Milton market is firmly in buyer’s territory . This figure is down from 0.33 in February and far below the 0.60 threshold that typically indicates a seller's market. Buyers are clearly being cautious — and for good reason. According to TRREB’s Chief Information Officer Jason Mercer ,  “Given the current trade uncertainty and the upcoming federal election, many households are likely taking a wait-and-see approach... Home buyers need to feel their employment situation is solid before committing to monthly mortgage payments over the long term.”
By Flowers Team Real Estate March 19, 2025
The Ultimate First-Time Homebuyer’s Guide: Navigating Milton’s Real Estate Market with Confidence
A close up of a cherry blossom tree branch with pink flowers in the spring.
By Flowers Team Real Estate March 18, 2025
April’s spring market in Milton is prime for top-dollar home sales. Get expert tips on curb appeal, prepping your property, and closing fast!
An aerial view of a living room filled with furniture and a fireplace.
By Flowers Team Real Estate March 17, 2025
Are you curious about your home’s value in Milton’s booming real estate market? Location, property features, and timing impact prices. Get a free valuation from Flowers Team today.
By Flowers Team Real Estate March 11, 2025
Buyers Hold the Power in Milton’s Resale Market - February 2025 saw continued advantages for home buyers in Milton, with an ample selection of listings keeping competition low. Home sales dipped compared to the same time last year, while new listings remained strong—creating favourable conditions for those looking to negotiate the best deal.
By Flowers Team Real Estate March 3, 2025
Selling your home in the spring isn’t just about listing it—it’s about making sure it stands out in a competitive market. Buyers make quick decisions based on how your home looks, feels, and even smells. If you want to sell fast and for top dollar, here’s why taking the right steps matters: 1. First Impressions Can Make or Break a Sale 💡 Buyers form an opinion within seconds of arriving at your home. A well-manicured lawn, a freshly painted front door, and a welcoming entrance can mean the difference between a showing that turns into an offer—or one that ends before it even begins. 2. A Clean Home Feels More Valuable 🧼 Buyers associate cleanliness with care—if they see dust, grime, or clutter, they may assume the home hasn’t been well maintained. Deep cleaning and decluttering make spaces feel bigger, brighter, and more inviting. 3. Decluttering Helps Buyers See Themselves in Your Home 🏡 When buyers walk into a space filled with personal photos, trinkets, and clutter, they see your home—not theirs. Staging and decluttering create a neutral, inviting atmosphere that helps buyers visualize their future in your space. 4. Good Lighting Makes Rooms Look Bigger & Brighter ☀ Buyers love bright, airy homes—dark spaces can feel small and uninviting. By maximizing natural light, swapping heavy curtains for sheers, and using mirrors strategically, you can enhance your home’s appeal instantly. 5. Small Repairs Can Lead to Bigger Offers 🔨 Peeling paint, a leaky faucet, or a squeaky door might seem minor, but they signal neglect to buyers. Taking care of small fixes before listing shows that your home has been well cared for—and helps avoid buyers negotiating for unnecessary repairs. 
Ice dam roof
By Flowers Team Real Estate February 26, 2025
Winter can be tough on homes, and with the recent milder weather, ice dams are becoming a real threat for homeowners. If left unchecked, these icy buildups can lead to costly repairs and serious water damage inside your home. But don’t worry—we’re here to help you understand what ice dams are, how they form, and most importantly, how to prevent or get rid of them.
By Flowers Team Real Estate February 21, 2025
Discover how GO Transit simplifies commuting from Milton with eco-friendly, affordable travel. Explore top destinations stress-free while saving time and money.
By Flowers Team Real Estate February 20, 2025
French Immersion, STEM, or AP schools in Milton, ON offer great programs for every child. Get tips on enrollment, zoning, and more to find the perfect fit.
By Flowers Team Real Estate February 8, 2025
As we step into the new year, the Milton real estate market has been buzzing with activity. With interest rates stabilizing and more buyers re-entering the market, January 2025 saw some significant shifts compared to the previous months. Let's dive into the numbers and what they mean for buyers and sellers in Milton.
More Posts
Share by: